Analyst clarifies: end of PlayStation discs doesn't mean Sony made the right call

Full text

Last week, analyst Daniel Ahmad compared the end of physical PlayStation games to the end of disc drives in Apple laptops, noting that nobody these days really seems to care about PC games having gone all-digital . The full post was lengthy and nuanced, but the internet tends not to read that far (congrats on making it over 50 words into this article, by the way), so now he's further clarifying what he meant on social media.

"When I compared Sony stopping disc production to CD drives being removed from computers, I'm talking in the context of games shipping on disc," Ahmad says on Bluesky . "Obviously you can buy an external drive for a PC, but virtually no modern PC game. This isn't me saying 'Wow I love Sony and they are great for doing this', it's to say that PC is essentially 100% digital and you'll be hard pressed to find anyone pining for the days of physical PC games."

Look, I like old-school, big box PC games and collect them here and there, but even as I cling to physical console games I'm willing to admit that the ship has long since sailed for physical computer games. There are all kinds of things making physical versions of modern PC games impractical, from the lack of disc drives on most retail computers to the inordinate amount of discs a modern PC install would require.

Ahmad reiterates the central point from his original post: "Regardless of whether it's bringing physical back, or embracing digital, the conversation needs to shift to consumer rights and what a license should enable. Stop Killing Games was one part of it, but gifting, family sharing, refunds, and other aspects are just as important."

That gets to the key difference separating digital games on console from those on PC. Steam dominates computer game distribution, with easy ways to gift games, solid refund policies, and built-in family sharing options. Valve is pressed into offering those kinds of features because it faces competition from other digital storefronts and the convenience of pirated games, but it would be a lot better for consumers if those kinds of features were required on digital stores by law.

We don't know what the PlayStation Store will look like when physical disc production ends, but none of the three console manufacturers have offered digital storefronts on par with those on PC, never mind something in line with what groups like Stop Killing Games are dreaming of. While I'd love for physical games to exist forever, I'm not confident they will. That's why, as Ahmad suggests, we need to be pushing for stronger ownership rights for our digital goods.

These are the best physical games to grab while you still can.